Open captions are part of the picture, closed captions are a separate track
Open captions are drawn into the video frames, so every viewer sees them and no one can turn them off. They are also called burned-in or hardcoded captions.
Closed captions travel next to the video as a separate text track, such as an SRT or WebVTT file. The player shows them only when the viewer switches them on, usually with a CC button. The W3C, which writes the web accessibility standard WCAG, uses the same split: closed captions can be turned on and off, open captions cannot.
| Open captions | Closed captions | |
|---|---|---|
| Where the text lives | In the video picture | In a separate file or track (SRT, WebVTT, SCC) |
| Viewer can turn them off | No | Yes |
| Viewer can change size and color | No, the look is fixed | Often, in the player or TV settings |
| Shows in apps that ignore caption files | Yes | No |
| Several languages on one video | One language per video file | One track per language |
| Fix a typo after publishing | Render and upload the video again | Replace the caption file |
| Text a platform can read and index | No, the words are pixels | Yes, the words are text |
When to use open captions
Use open captions when the video will play somewhere you cannot attach a caption file, or where you want every viewer to see the words. Short social videos are the main case. In a 2019 Verizon Media and Publicis Media study, reported by Forbes, 69% of people said they watch video with the sound off in public places, and 80% said they are more likely to finish a video when captions are available.
Open captions also let you control the look: the font, the size, the position and word by word highlighting stay exactly as you designed them. The cost is that viewers cannot hide them, enlarge them or switch language.
- Instagram Reels and TikTok, where you want your own wording and style on screen.
- Videos shared in messaging apps, presentations and email, which ignore caption files.
- Ads and silent autoplay feeds, where most people never turn the sound on.
- Screenings and events where you cannot rely on the player's caption settings.
When to use closed captions
Use closed captions when the platform accepts a caption file. Viewers can turn them off, make them larger, and choose another language if you upload more than one track. The words stay as text, so the platform can read them, and you can fix a mistake by replacing the file instead of the video.
YouTube accepts SRT, WebVTT, SBV, TTML, DFXP and the broadcast formats SCC and EBU-STL, according to YouTube Help. Facebook, LinkedIn and X accept an SRT file when you post a video. Instagram and TikTok can add their own automatic captions, but in November 2026 we found no official way to upload your own SRT file to either app.
Are open captions the same as subtitles?
No. The open or closed part describes how the text is delivered. Captions and subtitles describe what the text contains, and either one can be open or closed.
Captions are written for viewers who cannot hear the audio. They include speech plus sounds that matter, such as [door slams] or [music stops], and who is speaking. Subtitles assume the viewer can hear and usually only translate or transcribe the dialogue. Subtitles for the deaf and hard of hearing (SDH) are subtitles that add the sound and speaker information, according to the Described and Captioned Media Program (DCMP).
What open caption means at a movie theater
An open caption showing displays the dialogue and sound descriptions on the cinema screen for the whole audience. AMC Theatres labels these showtimes Open Caption (On-Screen Subtitles).
At other showings, US theaters offer closed captions on a personal device at your seat. A US Department of Justice rule under the Americans with Disabilities Act, published in December 2016, requires theaters that show digital movies to have these individual captioning devices and staff who can help with them. The rule does not require open caption showings.
Do open captions meet accessibility rules?
Yes. WCAG success criterion 1.2.2, Captions (Prerecorded), is a Level A requirement, and the W3C lists both open captions (technique G93) and closed captions (technique G87) as ways to meet it. What matters is that the captions are accurate, complete and in sync with the audio.
Closed captions give viewers more control. On televisions and set-top boxes, FCC rules (47 CFR 79.103) require equipment to let viewers change how closed captions look, including font, size and color. Open captions cannot offer that, so keep burned-in text large and high contrast.
Use both: burn captions in and upload the file
Many creators publish both versions from the same caption lines: an MP4 with open captions for Reels and TikTok, and the SRT file for YouTube, LinkedIn and X. Both come from one transcript, so the wording matches everywhere.
SoundHalo's Add subtitles tool returns both from one upload: the MP4 with the captions burned in and the SRT with the same lines.
- Upload the video to Add subtitles, or bring your own SRT or WebVTT file.
- Check every line and its timing, and fix names and numbers.
- Pick a style: standard subtitles or word by word captions sized for vertical video.
- Download the MP4 with open captions and the SRT for platforms that take closed captions.